« From the jokes-that-write-themselves dept. | Main| A note to Ray Ozzie »

A quote to remember...


Read this today on Slashdot, talking about Neal Stephenson....
This rung a bell for me: I have a degree in sculpture, and one of the first and most lasting lessons I learned is that your choice of tools shape the final work just as much as your intention does, if not more. The process matters; it effects the end result in subtle, hard-to-identify ways. I did an experiment when I was a student, I carved two marble busts (1/3 life size, I was poor), both of the same model. With one I used only hand tools: chisels, rasps, sandpaper, picks, etc. With the second one, I used only power tools: air hammer, sander, dremel, etc. (yes, that one took about a 5th of the time) I was pretty equally skilled with both kinds of tools, and although I was intending to create the same piece each time, they came out very very different. You can't tell from looking which tools I used to make which bust, but one is far "harder".... more aggressive in the expression, people say it seems arrogant. The other looks wistful, serene, relaxed, playful. Obviously just an anecdote, but it made a big impression on me.

Both from the same model, both from the same initial study I made in plasticene. The process matters.

I think I might need to get a tattoo.  "The process matters."  I can't think of a greater truism -- in every walk of life.

Can you think of ways the process matters?  Whether in software design, politics, art, business, or love... is there a time when the outcome is independent of the cycle of cause and effect that brought it into being?

Comments

1 - Interesting observation... some related examples off the top of my head:

Waxing a car - With an orbital buffer vs. by hand

Rush - On CD vs. live, in concert

Coffee - Pre-ground vs. grind-your-own

2 - A new Neal Stephenson novel! How did you scoop me on that!?! Emoticon

3 - nice post man. couldn't agree more. unless i could. in which case, i would. but i couldn't, so i don't. Emoticon

4 - That is another way of saying the end does not justify the means...

Post A Comment

:-D:-o:-p:-x:-(:-):-\:angry::cool::cry::emb::grin::huh::laugh::lips::rolleyes:;-)

Search 

Disclaimer 

Welcome to Escape Velocity!

Opinions expressed here by Nathan T. Freeman are not necessarily those of his employer. However, there's a decent chance they are, so check with them if you really want to know.

But really... do you need that kind of validation? Are the opinions expressed here in doubt?

MiscLinks